Really not sure what you mean at all but you have some serious fundamental flaws with your code so I'll address those. 
//We can define variables outside a while loop 
//and use those inside the loop so lets do that
Map trusterMap = new HashMap<String,ArrayList<String>>();
//i is not a "good" variable name, 
//since it doesn't explain it's purpose
Int count = 0;
while(myScanner.hasNextInt()) {    
    //Get the truster and trustee
    Int truster = myScanner.nextInt();
    Int trustee = myScanner.nextInt();
    //Originally you had:
    // String listname = truster + i;
    //I assume you meant something else here 
    //since the listname variable is already used
    //Add the truster concated with the count to the array
    //Note: when using + if the left element is a string 
    //then the right element will get autoboxed to a string
    //Having read your comments using a HashMap is the best way to do this.
    ArrayList<String> listname = new ArrayList<String>();
    listname.add(truster);
    trusterMap.put(truster + count, listname);
    i++;
}
Further, you are storing in myScanner a stream of Ints that will get fed in to the array, but which each have very different meanings (truster and trustee). Are you trying to read these in from a file, or user input? There are better ways of handling this and if you comment below with what you mean I'll update with a suggested solution.