I'm trying to display an alert if the value is equal or great than the minimum value and less than the maximum set value. Some how if I set dob to '01-09-1996' the alert is still triggered? Would somebody point out what I'm doing wrong? Thank you. 
$(function() {
    $('#date1 input').autotab_magic().autotab_filter('numeric');
    $(".eligibilityform").submit(function(e) {
        // Input Values
        var day = $("#day").val();
        var month = $("#month").val();
        var year = $("#year").val();
        // DOB Value
        var dob = new Date(day + '-' + month + '-' + year);
        // DOB Rules
        var mindob = new Date("01-09-1996");
        var maxdob = new Date("31-08-2000");
        // DOB Eligibility
        if (dob >= mindob && dob <= maxdob) {
            alert("Welcome");
            // Season Eligibility
            var spring2015min = new Date("01-09-1997");
            var spring2015max = new Date("31-08-1998");
            if (dob >= spring2015min && dob <= spring2015max) {
                alert("Spring 2015");
            }
            var summer2015min = new Date("01-09-1997");
            var summer2015max = new Date("31-08-1999");
            if (dob >= summer2015min && dob <= summer2015max) {
                alert("Summer 2015");
            }
            var autumn2015min = new Date("01-01-1998");
            var autumn2015max = new Date("31-08-1999");
            if (dob >= autumn2015min && dob <= autumn2015max) {
                alert("Autumn 2015");
            }
            var spring2016min = new Date("01-09-1998");
            var spring2016max = new Date("31-08-1999");
            if (dob >= spring2016min && dob <= spring2016max) {
                alert("Spring 2016");
            }
            var summer2016min = new Date("01-09-1998");
            var summer2016max = new Date("31-08-2000");
            if (dob >= summer2016min && dob <= summer2016max) {
                alert("Summer 2016");
            }
            var autumn2016min = new Date("01-01-1998");
            var autumn2016max = new Date("31-08-2000");
            if (dob >= autumn2016min && dob <= autumn2016max) {
                alert("Autumn 2016");
            }
        } else {
            alert("Sorry");
        }
        return false;
    });
});
Answer
// Eligibility
$(function() {
  $('#date1 input').autotab_magic().autotab_filter('numeric');
  $('.error-message').hide();
  $('.success-message').hide();
  $('.seasons').hide();
  $('.seasons li').hide();
  $(".eligibilityform").submit(function(e){
    // Input Values
    var day = $("#day").val();
    var month = $("#month").val();
    var year = $("#year").val();
    // DOB Value
    var dob = new Date(month+'/'+day+'/'+year);
    // DOB Rules
    var mindob = new Date("09/01/1997");
    var maxdob = new Date("08/31/2000");
    // DOB Eligibility
    if (dob >= mindob && dob <= maxdob) {
      $('.success-message').show();
      $('.intro-message').hide();
      $('.error-message').hide();
      $('.eligibilityform').hide();
      $('.seasons').show();
      // Season Eligibility
      var spring2015min = new Date("09/01/1997");
      var spring2015max = new Date("08/31/1998");
      if (dob >= spring2015min && dob <= spring2015max){
              $('.seasons li.one').show();
      }
      var summer2015min = new Date("09/01/1997");
      var summer2015max = new Date("08/31/1999");
      if (dob >= summer2015min && dob <= summer2015max){
        $('.seasons li.two').show();
      }
      var autumn2015min = new Date("01/01/1998");
      var autumn2015max = new Date("08/31/1999");
      if (dob >= autumn2015min && dob <= autumn2015max){
        $('.seasons li.three').show();
      }
      var spring2016min = new Date("09/01/1998");
      var spring2016max = new Date("08/31/1999");
      if (dob >= spring2016min && dob <= spring2016max){
        $('.seasons li.four').show();
      }
      var summer2016min = new Date("09/01/1998");
      var summer2016max = new Date("08/31/2000");
      if (dob >= summer2016min && dob <= summer2016max){
        $('.seasons li.five').show();
      }
      var autumn2016min = new Date("01/01/1998");
      var autumn2016max = new Date("08/31/2000");
      if (dob >= autumn2016min && dob <= autumn2016max){
        $('.seasons li.six').show();
      }
    } else {
      $('.intro-message').hide();
      $('.success-message').hide();
      $('.error-message').show();
    }
    return false;
  });
});
 
     
     
    