Select multiple rows from MySQL tables for 1 user

Question

For easier explaination I will try to simplify everything.

I have 3 SQL tables: Users, Certs, Serv

In Users table are stored details about unique users.

In Certs table are stored details about certificates and UserId of user who have this certificate (1 user can have multiple certificates)

In Serv table are stored details about sea services and UserId of user (like Certs table, 1 user can have multiple entries in Serv table)

SAMPLE DATA

Users

UserId  Name
1       John
2       Lisa

Certs

Id  UserId  CertName
1   1       A
2   1       B
3   1       C
4   2       A
5   2       C

Serv

UserId  Name
1       SA
1       SB
1       SC
1       SD
2       S2A

I need to retrieve output via PHP something like (where UserId = 1) also for reality there will be more columns from each table (for example more details of certificates like date of issue, date of expire, place of issue and so on):

Personal details:
Name
John

Certificates:
Certificate Id    Certificate Name
1                 A 
2                 B
3                 C

Sea Services:
Sea Service Name
SA
SB
SC
SD

But I got wrong output, duplicated entries, that because joining 2 tables with UserId in whose are multiple records with this UserId.

PHP CODE

$users = $con->prepare("
    select u.Name 
           ,GROUP_CONCAT(c.Id SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Id
           ,GROUP_CONCAT(c.certsName SEPARATOR '<br>') AS certsName 
           ,GROUP_CONCAT(s.Name SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Name         
    from users u
    left join certs c on u.UserId = c.UserId
    left join serv s on u.UserId = s.UserId 
    where u.UserId = ?
");
$users->bind_param('i', $GetUserId);
$users->execute();

$users->bind_result(
    $userName,
    $certId,            
    $certName,          
    $servName
);

<?php 
while ($users->fetch()) {
?>

<span>Personal Details</span>
<div class="grid-group">
    <div class="grid-column">
        <div class="grid-item header">User Name </div> 
    </div>
    <div class="grid-column">
        <div class="grid-item"><?php echo $userName; ?></div>       
    </div>
</div>

<span>Certificates</span>
<div class="grid-group">
    <div class="grid-column">
        <div class="grid-item header">Certificate Id</div> 
        <div class="grid-item header">Certificate Name</div> 
    </div>
    <div class="grid-column">
        <div class="grid-item"><?php echo $certId; ?></div> 
        <div class="grid-item"><?php echo $certName; ?></div>       
    </div>
</div>

<span>Sea Services</span>
<div class="grid-group">
    <div class="grid-column">
        <div class="grid-item header">Sea Service Name</div> 
    </div>
    <div class="grid-column">
        <div class="grid-item"><?php echo $servName; ?></div>       
    </div>
</div>

<?php } ?>

You can check SQL FIDDLE to see what results selecting, duplicating rows.

Have you ideas how can I achieve desired output without duplicates?

UPDATE

After using GROUP_CONCAT with DISTINCT It's still wrong. Imagine that In Serv table I have columns like: UserId, Name, Rank and Country

If the same user worked in different companies (this Name in example - Company Name) with the same rank in different countries, It selecting wrong data. For example:

Serv table (SQL)

UserId  Name     Rank        Country
1       SA       Captain     USA
1       SB       Captain     USA
1       SC       Captain     RUS
1       SD       Captain     ENG
2       S2A      Engineer    USA 

If I use query like this:

select u.Name 
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct c.Id SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Id
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct c.certsName SEPARATOR '<br>') AS certsName 
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct s.Name SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Name  
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct s.Rank SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Rank
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct s.Country SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Country        
from users u
left join certs c on u.UserId = c.UserId
left join serv s on u.UserId = s.UserId 
where u.UserId = ?

So GROUP_CONCAT(DISTINCT..) returning me in following:

......
Sea Services:
Sea Service Name    Rank      Country
SA                  Captain   USA
SB                            RUS
SC                            ENG
SD                        

Only first row have rank and first 3 rows have countries returned, but in database are stored ranks and countries for every row.

Full desired output with this data should be like this:

Personal details:
Name
John

Certificates:
Certificate Id    Certificate Name
1                 A 
2                 B
3                 C

Sea Services:
Sea Service Name    Rank      Country
SA                  Captain   USA
SB                  Captain   USA             
SC                  Captain   RUS
SD                  Captain   ENG

You can check It at SQL FIDDLE

UPDATE 2

If I remove DISTINCT I got following output:

Sea Service Name    Rank        Country
SA                  Captain     USA
SA                  Captain     USA
SA                  Captain     USA
SB                  Captain     USA
SB                  Captain     USA
SB                  Captain     USA
SC                  Captain     RUS
SC                  Captain     RUS
SC                  Captain     RUS
SD                  Captain     ENG
SD                  Captain     ENG
SD                  Captain     ENG

If I'm using DISTINCT I got like this:

Sea Services:
Sea Service Name    Rank      Country
SA                  Captain   USA
SB                            RUS
SC                            ENG
SD                        

But It should be:

Sea Services:
Sea Service Name    Rank      Country
SA                  Captain   USA
SB                  Captain   USA             
SC                  Captain   RUS
SD                  Captain   ENG

UPDATE 3

Imagine that I have fixed width of columns and I have long Sea Service Name which will be wrapped to new row:

Sea Service Name |  Rank  | Country
-----------------|--------|---------
This is long Sea | Captain| USA
Service Name     |--------|---------
-----------------| Captain| RUS
 Other Name      |--------|---------
-----------------| Captain| ENG
Another long Sea |--------|---------
Service Name     | Master | USA                        
-----------------|--------|---------
Other Sea Serv   |
-----------------|

As you see now each column are separate, rows didn't match. But It should be like 1 row. So I think I can't achieve It with GROUP_CONCAT, looks like I need another way.

How It looks in real:

Answer 1

You are missing a group by clause :

select u.Name 
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct c.Id SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Id
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct c.certsName SEPARATOR '<br>') AS certsName 
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct s.Name SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Name  
       ,(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(ss.Rank SEPARATOR '<br>') FROM users uu
         LEFT OUTER JOIN serv ss ON (uu.UserId = ss.UserId)
         WHERE uu.user_id = u.user_id) as Rank
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(distinct s.Country SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Country        
from users u
left join certs c on u.UserId = c.UserId
left join serv s on u.UserId = s.UserId 
where u.UserId = ?

Also, I've added distinct to your GROUP_CONCAT since you are left joining to multiple tables with multiples rows for each user, you will have multiple duplicates.

Answer 2

This looks like a mad amount of effort to avoid multiple queries..

Keep it simple

You could run the query:

SELECT ...        
FROM users u
LEFT JOIN certs c on u.UserId = c.UserId
LEFT JOIN serv s on u.UserId = s.UserId 
WHERE u.UserId = ?

And separate the certificates and services in the application logic.

Or just run two or three separate queries:

    SELECT * FROM users u WHERE u.UserId = ?
    SELECT * FROM certs c WHERE c.UserId = ?
    SELECT * FROM serv s  WHERE s.UserId = ?

Although there is the overhead of 3 queries, with the right indexing these will be crazy fast and you've reduced the amount of redundant data changing hands.

These simple queries are easily debugged and understood. The query you have is very complex for this operation and even minor changes are already causing you issues.

Also, please please please separate out your formatting from the database. If I was having trouble with spacing in a layout, one of the LAST places I'd look is the database query.

Keeping the separate layers of your application separate allows you to deal with one problem at a time and change the display of your data without worrying about the data itself.

Answer 3

This can be simply done using application logic after getting entire data with duplicated entries and separating them in PHP. Always remember you can have multiple application servers to distribute its load but you would always prefer to have single Database server on which you would want minimum load of queries. Also Customer load can be distributed among application servers, where as same number of clients would be accessing same database.

Answer 4

You needed to add DISTINCT to GROUP_CONCAT because you get join n rows from certs to m rows from serv, resulting in n*m rows with lots of duplicates.

But when you do your GROUP_CONCAT for each table using Derived Tables you get only one row per table:

select u.Name 
       ,c.Id
       ,c.certsName 
       ,s.Name  
       ,s.Rank
       ,s.Country        
from users u
left join
 ( select UserId
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(Id SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Id
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(certsName SEPARATOR '<br>') AS certsName 
   from certs
   where UserId = 1
   group by UserId
 ) as c on u.UserId = c.UserId
left join 
 ( select UserId
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(Name SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Name  
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(Rank SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Rank
       ,GROUP_CONCAT(Country SEPARATOR '<br>') AS Country        
   from serv
   where UserId = 1
   group by UserId
 ) as s on u.UserId = s.UserId 
where u.UserId = 1

See Fiddle

Of course the advice to submit seperate queries is still the best answer, everything else is just a workaround solution.

Answer 5

SELECT 
u.name,
(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(c.id SEPARATOR '<br>') FROM certs c WHERE c.userId = u.userId) AS Id,
(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(c.CertsName SEPARATOR '<br>') FROM certs c WHERE c.userId = u.userId) AS certsName,
(SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(s.Name SEPARATOR '<br>') FROM serv s WHERE s.userId = u.userId) AS Name
FROM users u WHERE u.userId = ?

Answer 6

SELECT MULTIPLE ROWS FROM TABLE1(TB1) AND TABLE2(TB2) : CM1_1 , CM1_2 FROM TABLE1 AND CM2_1 , CM2_2 , CM2_3 FROM TABLE2

SELECT CM1_1 , CM1_2 , CM2_1 , CM2_2 , CM2_3 FROM TB1, TB2 WHERE  CM1_2 = '1' AND CM1_1 = CM2_1  AND CM2_3 = 'John'