The method takes 1 array and using random to shuffle the array the value of rndm1-4 didn't change. and after the loop, it acts normal. I think the problem is in the while loop.
public static string[] Shuffle(string[] array)
{
    string str1, str2, str3, str4;
    Random rnd1 = new Random();
    Random rnd2 = new Random();
    Random rnd3 = new Random();
    Random rnd4 = new Random();
    int rndm1 = rnd1.Next(3);
    int rndm2 = rnd2.Next(3);
    int rndm3 = rnd3.Next(3);
    int rndm4 = rnd4.Next(3);
    
    while ((rndm1 != rndm2) && (rndm1 != rndm3) && (rndm1 != rndm4) 
        && (rndm2 != rndm3) && (rndm2 != rndm4) && (rndm3 != rndm4))
    {
        rndm1 = rnd1.Next(3);
        rndm2 = rnd2.Next(3);
        rndm3 = rnd3.Next(3);
        rndm4 = rnd4.Next(3);
    }
    
    str1 = array[0];
    str2 = array[1];
    str3 = array[2];
    str4 = array[3];
    array[rndm1] = str1;
    array[rndm2] = str2;
    array[rndm3] = str3;
    array[rndm4] = str4;
    return array;
}
 
     
    