2

I'm experimenting with Samba shares at home and I'm trying to understand how symbolic links work.
I have a few network shares on a couple of machines that run a mix of Windows and Ubuntu or Debian distros.
I'm trying to understand a few things:

  • is it possible to allow for the creation of symbolic links (from any client) inside the shares and across shares but not outside shared paths? For example if I have /srv/share1 and /srv/share2 would it be possible to link:

    /srv/share1/link -> /srv/share1/file
    

    and

    /srv/share2/link -> /srv/share1/file
    

    but not any file outside these 2 directories?

  • is it possible to make symlinks "transparent" on any client or specific clients when mounting the shares? Are there specific options I should use when mounting them on other machines to see links as such?
    Right now mounting them using cifs shows symlinks as it was a normal files (I didn't set any options using the command beside authentication).
    This answer: Deleting Ubuntu folder symlink deletes target folder's contents when done via OSX & Samba seems to support this behaviour.

  • I'd like to get a clearer understanding on which are the pros and cons of various options used to manage links; in particular which are the advantages and disadvantages of:

    [global]
    allow insecure wide links = Yes
    unix extensions = Yes
    wide links = Yes
    

    instead of:

    [global]
    unix extensions = No  # Does this imply UNIX clients cannot create symlinks?
    wide links = Yes
    

    besides the obvious security problem related to allow insecure wide links being turned on.
    The above config is from: https://unix.stackexchange.com/q/5120/181086

A partial answer is given here: creating symbolic links on networked drive but it's related to Windows.
Other answers such as: Ubuntu + latest samba version, symlinks no longer work on share mounted in windows
Creating a Symlink in an NTFS share
aren't really recent and don't go in-depth in the reasons why it does or doesn't work.
Finally this one I didn't understand Samba Linux shares -- Why won't windows machines display/follow symbolic links?.

devster
  • 21
  • 1
  • 1
  • 3

0 Answers0