3

Ok, this one is doing my head in...

I have just bought and installed a Netgear DGN2200 Wireless-N router, and it's all working find, but I can't get one laptop to communicate with it using WPA2.

All the other computers are working fine:

  • Ubuntu + Netgear WN111v2
  • Windows 7 + RTL8191SE
  • FreeBSD + RTL8192E
  • HTC Wildfire

All perfect.

The one that won't connect is Windows XP SP3 with an Atheros AR5007EG card.

It connects and works fine with encryption turned off (I actually have 2 SSIDs set up on the router - one encrypted and one open but isolated)

Connecting to the encrypted SSID it appears to authenticate with the WPA2 PSK, but then takes forever acquiring an IP address. It appears eventually to fail and then suddenly instantly succeed. The IP it gets is a valid one from the router.

But, I am unable to ping, or anything, on the network.

Atheros diagnostics are telling me there are lots of packets being retransmitted and lots of CRC errors in reception.

I'm thinking I may just go and try my Ubuntu Live CD to see if I can connect OK with that...

Oh, before you ask, yes, Windows Updates are all up to date, and I have just installed the latest Atheros drivers and client utility (first thing I tried).

It just defies logic (or I just need a fresh brain to mention the obvious - whatever that is)

Oh, and I know it's not the Netgear router - I have FreeBSD embedded machine with an Atheros card in it that I am running in HostAP mode with WPA2 and the laptop is exhibiting the same symptoms when trying to connect to that.


UPDATE

Ok, so I am posting this update from my Ubuntu Live CD on the offending laptop. It connected in about 1 second - maybe less ;)

So it looks like it may be the driver - I have that on a USB key to try next...


UPDATE

The driver update doesn't work with this card unfortunately.


UPDATE

Ok, get this...

If I set up a second SSID on the router using the exact same settings as the primary one, I can connect perfectly with WPA2.

Hennes
  • 65,804
  • 7
  • 115
  • 169
Majenko
  • 32,964

2 Answers2

1

You probably have neighbours nearby with wireless routers all using the same channel (most routers default to channel 6). Try switching to a different channel (to use different frequencies) and see if that helps.

  Network Stumbler
  http://www.netstumbler.com/

You can use Network Stumbler to find out what channels all the wireless routers in your area are using, which can be helpful in selecting one that's not being used.

1

If the thread Getting Atheros AR5212 Wireless Cards to Work with Windows XP relates to your problem, then the solution there was to use the AWLC4030 Driver v4.0.0.1733.

harrymc
  • 498,455