18

Is it possible to put the entire operating system on a ram disk? If I have 16 GB of RAM and it is an Intel Xeon. I don't have an SSD and my hard drive is killing my boot time. So can I just allocate some of my ram to work as if it were an SSD and install windows and vital software on it, to gain super fast speed. Or is it more trouble then its worth and would be better off just buying an SSD?

James Smith
  • 307

7 Answers7

31

Your idea (as cool as it is) unfortunately won't work in practice:

  1. The RAM disk would be wiped whenever you turn your PC off, reboot it, or if you lose power.

  2. 16 GB is not enough RAM. Don't forget you need to keep some RAM aside to use as, you know, regular RAM. So at best you might be able to do a 12 GB RAM disk. Well, 12 GB doesn't meet Windows 10's minimum free hard drive space requirement.

  3. Software-based RAM disks actually run on top of an already installed operating system. What you'd need is a way to create a RAM disk at a hardware level, so that Windows actually thinks it's talking to a real IDE/SATA/SCSI hard drive. That would require purchasing a special RAM disk card (for example, this). Incidentally, this would also solve problems 1 and 2, but the cost is insane.

So yeah, you need an SSD ;-)

Boann
  • 1,165
misha256
  • 11,543
  • 8
  • 60
  • 70
5

Yes you can and 16G RAM are more than enough

  • Shrink the size of any windows iso using tools like ntlite or winreducer
  • Feed the output wim in to NtSetup
  • Boot the output VHD and configure your Windows - add firadisk driver
  • Mount the VHD from your normal OS and capture it with wimlib
  • Apply the output wim to a new VHD using the compact=lzx switch
  • Use grub4dos to map that VHD in RAM and boot it

That's a rough sketch of the procedure, it's a lot more complicated than it sounds but it can be done. I'm using a 1.2G Windows 10 VHD booted from RAM right now. Windows 10 support LZX compression on the fly. Windows 7 too but with the help of wofadk.sys.

If you're still interested ask for details.

phuclv
  • 30,396
  • 15
  • 136
  • 260
dim
  • 51
3

You can use grub to create a ramdisk then load a vhd image into it and boot it.
Then you can save the image to disk before shutdown saving your work. It does indeed work with windows 10 and does have a point over sshd because it reduces the write cycles to the drive, and ram is much faster than sshd. Minimum size you can make windows 10 up and running is 3.9 g stripping everything out you do not need.

mic84
  • 2,413
wmtdanimal
  • 31
2

Is it possible to put the entire operating system on a ram disk?

From some googling for "Windows bootable ramdisk" there are apparently ways to do it. I haven't tested them myself though.

You could also use a virtualisation platform to run a windows VM with a ramdrive as a backing store.

If I have 16 GB of RAM and it is an Intel Xeon.

16GB really isn't very much once you start talking installing software on ramdisks.

I don't have an SSD and my hard drive is killing my boot time. So can I just allocate some of my ram to work as if it were an SSD and install windows and vital software on it, to gain super fast speed.

The big problem here is that ramdisks are volatile. So even if you can get windows to run from a ramdrive and even if you have enough memory to run something that's not a crazy stripped down install, every time you do a cold boot you would have to re-copy stuff from your hard drive to the ram drive. If your goal is to reduce boot times that renders ramdrives fairly pointless.

Or is it more trouble then its worth and would be better off just buying an SSD?

Yes you would be much better off just buying a SSD.

user
  • 30,336
plugwash
  • 6,719
2

After booting, copy a directory to the ramdisk and use symbolic links to make that transparent to the OS.

But really, the OS already caches the disk using available ram.

No matter what, it won't help boot time, since the files are not copied to ram until after it boots, and you'll spend more time copying them.

The "live CD" of Linux systems often work using a ramdisk. But you wait for the compressed image to be read into ram, slowing boot time.

Compression...hmmm... if you have a fast Xeon but a slow disk, you could compress the drive and have less data to read from the disk.

Win10 should have fast-boot image caching though, so between that and defragmenting the disk your boot speed should be OK.

How slow is the boot speed you're complaining about?

JDługosz
  • 617
1

You could try getting a cheap SSD and Primocache. This software allows you to make a two tier caching system for any drive in your computer. The first tier usese the spare system ram, and the second tier uses an SSD.

The idea is that it writes changes to memory first, then to the ssd, and then when the system isn't busy, it writes the data to the actual slower drive.

30 day free trial http://www.romexsoftware.com/en-us/primo-cache/help.html

James Claydon
  • 11
-1

What you are after is running from a physical disk made up from ram, is automatically stored on permanent media on power loss, and restored when powered on.

It isn't a new idea by anymeans. If you are willing to shell out the cash, it has been around for a while:

http://www.hyperossystems.co.uk/07042003/hardware.htm

Fozzedout
  • 1